Mr. Quintana's ASL Classes
Tuesday, December 3, 2013
Monday, December 2, 2013
What is ASL Idioms ? What are the difference between English and ASL Idioms ?
Indeed once we analyze many
signed phrases that some people commonly call "idioms" we do
find that those phrases are not idioms and instead are something else.
However, if we delve into the definition of the term "idiom" and use
that definition to "screen" the whole of ASL phraseology we certainly
find more than just "four" ASL idioms.
The trick is getting people to agree on what is an "idiom" and prevent people from pooh poohing your idiom examples and calling them metaphors or "metaphorical use of language."
Thus we must establish firm definitions (rules) if we are going to play the game:
The definition of a "metaphor" according to dictionary.com is:
1. A figure of speech in which a word or phrase that ordinarily designates one thing is used to designate another, thus making an implicit comparison, as in “a sea of troubles” or “All the world's a stage” (Shakespeare).
2. One thing conceived as representing another; a symbol: “Hollywood has always been
an irresistible, prefabricated metaphor for the crass, the materialistic, the
shallow, and the craven” (Neal Gabler).
So then, how is a metaphor different from an idiom?
The definition of an "idiom":
According to the 1993 Merriam-Webster dictionary, an idiom is “an expression in the usage of a language that is peculiar to itself either grammatically or in having a meaning that cannot be derived from the conjoined meanings of its elements” (575).
The trick is getting people to agree on what is an "idiom" and prevent people from pooh poohing your idiom examples and calling them metaphors or "metaphorical use of language."
Thus we must establish firm definitions (rules) if we are going to play the game:
The definition of a "metaphor" according to dictionary.com is:
1. A figure of speech in which a word or phrase that ordinarily designates one thing is used to designate another, thus making an implicit comparison, as in “a sea of troubles” or “All the world's a stage” (Shakespeare).
2. One thing conceived as representing another; a symbol: “
So then, how is a metaphor different from an idiom?
The definition of an "idiom":
According to the 1993 Merriam-Webster dictionary, an idiom is “an expression in the usage of a language that is peculiar to itself either grammatically or in having a meaning that cannot be derived from the conjoined meanings of its elements” (575).
Ah ha! There we go. The ASL idiom "TRAIN GONE" means "no, I'm not going to repeat what I said." It isn't a metaphor because "the leaving of a train" is sufficiently different from the idea of "someone not repeating themselves" that you really can't make a direct connection between the two.
To be able to understand what is meant by an idiom you have to possess "insider" knowledge. You can't just look up the meaning of the individual words in a dictionary and piece together the meaning of an idiom.
You generally can figure out a metaphor without context or insider knowledge. It is likely that a person could figure out that the metaphor "sea of troubles" means to have a lot of problems. But without context or insider knowledge a would be unlikely to figure out that the idiom "kicked the bucket" means someone "He died." You might assume that someone was mad or that he messed up -- but died? No. So, an phrase becomes an idiom (and not just a metaphor) when the phrase's meaning moves so far from the literal interpretation that it makes no sense.
Consider this conversation about an idiom:
Bob: Hey John, what does the phrase "He kicked the bucket" mean?
John: Well, Bob, it means "He died."
Bob: That doesn't make any sense. What does a bucket have to do with dying?!?
John: I don't know. It's just an idiom.
Compare that with this conversation about a metaphor:
John: Well, Bob, it means "He died."
Bob: Eh, I don't get it.
John: Well, it's like you are saying his spirit has passed on to the next life.
Bob: Oh, I get it. "He passed away" is saying that dying is like "passing through a door into another realm." That is sort of poetic.
John: Yah, it is metaphorical.
In a metaphor the meaning has been abstracted but held on to.
In an idiom the meaning has been obliterated and replaced.
Here are some ASL idioms for your consideration.
[Note: Do not copy and paste this list to some other website without permission. And then even if you get permission you need to be giving credit and a link back to Lifeprint. Don't take the list and make a few changes and call it your own. I'm working on this as an article for eventual peer reviewed publication.]
1. TRAIN GONE = missed opportunity to know what is being talked about
2. CIGARETTE GONE = missed opportunity to know what is being talked about. Note, this is a clever twist on the "train gone" idiom since some people say, TRAIN BACK! But you can't bring back a smoked cigarette.
3. FINISH TOUCH = been there, have physically been to a place
4. FISH = "I am done. It is over." This is a pun / idiom based on the fact that many Deaf when doing the sign for "FINISH" make a mouth movement that looks as if they were saying the word "fish."
5. BASEMENT = Stayed home, didn't go out.
6. "BY-A-HAIR" (pull a hair) = "Whew! That was a close one!" The signer does a sign that depicts the "pulling of a single hair" but the actual meaning has nothing to do with the pulling of a single piece of hair.
7. FISH-SWALLOW = gullible. The signer does a sign which depicts the swallowing of a fish but the actual meaning is that someone is gullible.
8. BLOW-BRAINS-OUT = Gee, oh wow, I can't believe that it (a certain piece of information) isn't coming to my mind. I know this but can't think of the right word, or information.
9. SCRATCH-FOREHEAD = I will never forget that. / "Scarred for life."
10. STRICT = "hard nosed" = unyielding, not flexible. This sign is interesting because the meaning of the sign is interpreted as "strict." You see the sign and you think "strict" -- you don't think of it as being an idiom. But if you consider the likely history of the sign you can see that it is a combination of the signs "HARD" and "NOSE." The phrase, "He (or she) is hard nosed," is obviously an idiom since the literal meaning has nothing to do with having a "hard nose."
Debatable idioms:
1.
Idioms are supposed to consist of "more than one word." So how is it that a single sign qualifies as an idiom? I'm not saying that a single sign in isolation qualifies as an idiom. "BASEMENT" out of context doesn't qualify as an idiom, but if a signer asks, "PAST WEEKEND what-DO YOU?" and gets a reply of "BASEMENT" that reply if interpreted literally would mean "I was in the basement all weekend" -- which is obviously more than a single word but has an actual meaning of "I stayed home and didn't go anywhere" -- which has nothing to do with an actual "basement."
Thursday, November 28, 2013
Wednesday, November 20, 2013
ASL 2 & 3- Project #1- ASL Song
ASL
2 & 3- Project #1- ASL Song
You
will introduce and perform a song of 2 minutes or more, but no longer than 4
minutes, for the class. You may record a video and bring it to me, or sign it
live in class.
The
English song lyric should be more than 16 lines and translate it into ASL
verison. Please submit both ASL and English song translation (typed or
neatly written) to Mr. Quintana.
Email:
Quintanaf@whitehouseisd.org
You will be
given class time to work on your songs.
ASL SONG
presentation IS DUE ON September 25th!
SIGNED
PORTION:
- YOU WILL SIGN TO THE CLASS
·
Your introduction of the song needs to include:
·
your name
·
fingerspell song title
·
fingerspell name of the artist
·
You need to sign the song CONCEPTUALLY and CONTEXTUALLY
correct.
·
What is the song REALLY saying? If the lyrics say, “Baby
you’re a firework,” is it actually saying that someone is an explosion in the
sky? NO! (Think about what it REALLY means!)
·
USE ASL! Do not sign word-for-word and think how the signs
can be used and manipulated to show a picture.
·
Keep in mind that sometimes the lyrics actually mean what
they say…don’t overthink it.
·
It needs to flow and show the beat, and mood, of the music.
·
SHOW THE EMOTION OF THE SONG
·
Look at your audience.
·
Your signing must be original. You may use others for
inspiration/ideas.
·
Be well practiced.
·
Your performance is your opportunity to shine. You
should be energetic, enthusiastic, and expressive!
·
Have your music prepared and ready to go - CD, radio, or iPod
with whatever necessary hardware to make it audible to the class
·
Being unprepared will
result in points lost.
·
Changing the song
performed the day of presentation without the teacher’s consent will result in
a 0!
·
DON’T WAIT UNTIL THE
LAST MINUTE! It shows in your performance, then it gets awkward.
Things to keep in mind when
picking a song:
- Teacher must pre-approve the song
·
No vulgar
language, discriminatory or sexual music allowed!
- Something that tells a story is usually easiest to interpret.
- If it has a lot of metaphors (a phrase that paints a picture, and has an alternate meaning) it may be hard to interpret. The choice is yours. No extra are given or taken away for this.
- Example: “Baby, you’re a firework.”
- Something more upbeat is usually best.
- Slow or romantic songs can be awkward and hard to sign.
WRITTEN
PORTION/ VISUAL AID:
- VISUAL AID:
a.
You will either turn in a video of you signing your song, or
sign it live for the class.
1.
You can turn it in on YouTube, a disc, flash drive, etc.-.
MAKE SURE IT WORKS!
2.
If you sign it live for the class, you will be videotaped for
grading, and self-evaluation purposes.
3.
YOU WILL SIGN ON THE
DAY YOU ARE TO PRESENT WHETHER YOU ARE READY OR NOT.
- GLOSSING:
a.
You will write a simple
ASL GLOSS next to, or below, your English lyrics of your signed
performance.
b.
You must include all the aspects listed below in the rubric.
1.
It must original. –Your signs and your words, not someone
else’s.
2.
GLOSS is written in ALL CAPITAL LETTERS.
c.
Don’t get “caught up” in the glossing part, and let it stop
you from being creative and using classifiers. The gloss is to show your
teacher you understand what to sign. Your teacher will be watching your
SIGNING, not your gloss.
- LYRICS:
a.
You MUST
have 2 copies of the lyrics.
1.
One will be turned in to your teacher for a daily grade.
2.
One will be kept with you and brought to class DAILY until
the conclusion of this assignment.
3. You will turn in an official copy of the
lyrics and gloss when it is your time to present.
Things to remember:
·
Wear clothing that is a solid color and contrasts
your skin tone.
·
Use a solid background (i.e. wall, sheet, blanket,
etc.)
·
NO GUM
·
No flashy/big jewelry. –It’s distracting and gets in
the way.
·
Hair needs to be pulled back and out of your face.
o
I can’t grade your facial expressions if I can’t see
them.
o
Constantly messing with your hair will result in
points taken off.
·
Your performance must BE ORIGINAL!
·
Bring your lyrics with you every day to class. Failure to do so will result in a 50% for the
day.
·
Show the beat and feel of the music with your signs
and body language.
·
HAVE FUN WITH
THIS!
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)